Dietary and exercise advice simultaneously better for obese

Empower & Inspire: Spread Health & Wellness

Giving dietary and exercise advice simultaneously produces better results than focusing on 1 behavior change at a time for obese people, said researchers from the Stanford School of Medicine in California.

Given the busy and stressful lives many people lead, advice on healthy eating or physical activity often ends up being just another source of stress. Many health professionals believe that people find multiple messages overwhelming and this has led to an emphasis on making small changes, one at a time.

However, some researchers suggest that this method may actually end up reducing compliance. Each subsequent change requires another bout of motivation which may, by then, be in short supply.

The current study was therefore designed to systematically test one method against the other to see which might be more beneficial long-term.

The researchers divided 200 participants into four groups. All participants were aged 45 years and older, did little exercise, ate fewer than five fruit and vegetable portions per day and had a higher than recommended saturated fat intake. They also reported elevated stress levels.

The four groups were given differing sequences of telephone-based advice:
– one group received exercise advice first, then nutrition advice was added after four months;
– a second group was given nutrition advice first, then exercise advice was added after four months;
– the third group received simultaneous delivery of nutrition and exercise advice; and
– a control group was advised on stress management only.

While all three groups showed positive increases in their dietary patterns relative to controls, there were differences in success when it came to physical activity. Participants who had received the exercise advice first significantly increased their physical activity levels at four months relative to controls, whereas physical activity did not increase significantly in the ‘simultaneous’ group at this early stage. However, by 12 months, both the exercise-first and simultaneous groups had increased their exercise to the nationally recommended levels.

In contrast, the group obtaining the nutrition advice first was not, on average, able to increase their exercise to the recommended levels by 12 months. Those in the simultaneous group were the only ones who succeeded in meeting the national recommendations for both dietary and physical activity behaviors at 12 months.

According to the authors, “The results suggest that, in the current population, delivering physical activity and dietary interventions simultaneously may result in the most positive sustained outcomes across these two important health behaviors.” Similarly, the potential interference effects of early dietary intervention on subsequent physical activity changes merit further study.

Source: Springer, USA

Leave a Comment